|
Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) Group Test (Edition 6) This report is no longer available on line. However it is still available for purchase in PDF, CD or print versions. Click here to purchase on line using our secure server. Foreword Welcome to the sixth edition of The NSS Group PKI Group Test. For this edition, we have once again divided the report into two sections, one devoted to PKI software, and the other covering PKI hardware (hardware security modules). We have also updated the introductory material to provide additional background information on the implementation and uses of PKI. Demand for, and interest in, our previous PKI reports has been tremendous, and we have had well in excess of 25,000 downloads since the first edition of the report was published. Feedback confirms we are providing a major source of much needed information and advice to security professionals, and the NSS Group PKI reports are considered the definitive guides to the PKI market place. The sixth edition of our PKI report provides independent and comprehensive technical evaluations of the current leading products in the market place, and we hope you find this latest edition as useful and informative as those which preceded it. Bob Walder TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION When is a PKI System Not A PKI System Cryptography Secret Key Cryptography Public Key Cryptography Digital Signatures Digital Certificates How Are Digital Certificates Used Certificate Enrolment Authentication vs.Authorization Alice Does e-Commerce Certificate Validation Certificate Revocation List (CRL) Online Certificate Status Protocol (OCSP) Basic Constraints Validation Process Other Uses For Digital Certificates Public Key Standards Certificate Management Protocol (CMP) Simple Certificate Enrolment Protocol (SCEP) Web-Based Enrolment PKCS 10 Application Support Securing The CA Root Keys In-House vs Outsourcing Responsibility and Liability The Division of Authority Brand Awareness Product Reviews Product Reviews Baltimore Unicert 5 Architecture UniCERT Certification Authority UniCERT Certificate Authority Operator UniCERT Certificate Status Server UniCERT Publisher UniCERT Registration Authority UniCERT WebRAO UniCERT RA eXchange UniCERT Protocol Handlers UniCERT Token Manager UniCERT Advanced Technology Installation Certification Authority PKI Editor RP Editor Registration Authority Register Authorise Collect Status Auditing and Reporting Client Checklist Pricing Verdict Contact Details BT Ignite Managed PKI 4.5.1 Architecture End User Managed PKI Administrator Issuing Centre Local Hosting Automated Administration Passcode Authentication Trusted Web Transactions for Web Applications Personal Trust Agent Certificate Management Tools Online Certificate Status Protocol Key Management Service Trusted Messaging for Microsoft Exchange Trusted IPSec for Check Point Secure Server Managed PKI Global Server Managed PKI Managed PKI for IPSec Installation Certificate Authority Registration Authority Configuration Certificate Management Auditing and Reporting Client Personal Trust Agent (PTA) Certificate Validation Module (CVM) Trusted Messaging for Microsoft Exchange Checklist Pricing Verdict Contact Details RSA Keon 6.5 Architecture Keon Certificate Authority Keon Registration Authority Keon KRM Keon OneStep Keon WebSentry Installation Certificate Authority Registration Authority Auditing and Reporting Client Keon Web Passport SecurID Passage e-Sign Checklist Pricing Verdict Contact Details Safelayer KeyOne 2.1 Architecture Private Secure Store (PSS) KeyOne CA KeyOne RA KeyOne RRA KeyOne CA Online Server KeyOne CA Online Browsing Server KeyOne LRA KeyOne WEB KeyOne Desktop KeyOne Toolkits Scryptor Installation Certificate Authority Off-line CA On-line CA Registration Authority KeyOne RA KeyOne LRA Auditing and Reporting Client Personal Certificate Operations KeyOne Desktop Checklist Pricing Verdict Contact Details SSH Certifier 2.0.6 Architecture SSH Certifier Administration Service CMP Service External Enrolment Client Service OCSP Responder Service Publishing Service SCEP Service Web Enrolment Service ODBC LDAP Hardware Security Modcules (HSM) SSH Token Master SSH Accession Certification Request Processing Installation Certificate Authority Registration Authority Auditing and Reporting Client Checklist Pricing Verdict Contact Details Hardware Product Reviews AEP SureWare Keyper Professional V2.2 Introduction Hardware Firmware The Adapter Authorisation Key (AAK) The Storage Master Key (SMK) Application Keys Keyper Administration Load Balancing Auditing Verdict Contact Details Chrysalis-ITS Luna SA Hardware K3 Chrysalis Crypotgraphic Engine Luna PED Firmware K3 Chrysalis Cryptographic Engine HSM Partitions Clients Network Trust Links (NTL) Secure Command Line Interface (SCLI) Secure Authentication and Access Control (SAAC) Secure Backup Token Secure Identity Management (SIM) High Availability and Load Balancing (HA) Updates Administration Auditing Programmability Verdict Contact Details nCipher nShield Hardware Software Security World KeySafe Applications Cryptographic Acceleration Web Services (XML) SSL Web Servers SSL Virtual Private Networks PKI Database Encryption Secure Code Execution SEE Application areas Verdict Contact Details Summary Appendix A Appendix B |